You've stopped explaining, stopped offering rewards, stopped giving more warning. The refusals hit welcome things as reliably as unwelcome ones, and that randomness is what makes this so disorienting. For a child with a PDA profile, even a demand for something they want can feel like a threat to their autonomy, and the pushback can come before the request has even landed.
Direct demands can set off the avoidance even when they're phrased politely. Explaining why something is good for them, or naming what happens if they don't, tends to add pressure rather than ease it. What often helps is moving from demands to invitations and observations. Depersonalize the task ("the shoes need to go on before we can leave" rather than "you need to put your shoes on"), say what you notice instead of giving an instruction ("I notice your backpack is still by the door"), and when you offer a choice, make sure either option is genuinely fine with you.Seeing the refusals as often driven by anxiety rather than choice can change how you respond, and make room for more patience on both sides.
What helps can shift as your child grows. With a younger child, much of the work is taking pressure out of everyday routines. With an older child or teen, planning things together, so they have a real say in how and when things get done, can make demands feel less like threats.- Say What You Notice: "I notice your shoes are still by the door." If even that lands as pressure, step back and let it go for now if it can wait. Make an Invitation: "I wonder if you'd like to shower now or after you finish your game." If your child pushes back, drop it and try again later in a calmer moment. Give Them a Real Say: "I'll get the snack. You let me know which kind you want." If they can't engage, it's fine to just do it yourself and keep things low-key.
Avoid saying “You have to do it now.” This can escalate the situation by increasing their anxiety and sense of being cornered. Similarly, “Why can’t you just listen?” implies fault and misunderstanding, which can further alienate your child and intensify their avoidance.
When faced with persistent demand avoidance, it’s essential to manage your own stress. Practice deep breathing or take a brief pause to reset. Remind yourself that your child's behavior is not a personal affront, but rather a reflection of their struggle. By maintaining calm, you model the behavior you wish to see and create a more supportive environment for both of you.
Easing pressure and rewording requests is the core approach. The first job is usually sorting your child's load into what's essential and what can be set aside for now.
- Which demands truly can't be dropped right now, and which could wait for a while?
- Does the pushback ease when a request comes from a timer, a list or the situation instead of you?
- Does even a gentle question, like asking what's wrong, set off resistance?
- Have the demands on your child piled up lately, at home or at school?
- Are the other adults in your child's life on board, or worried that lowering demands is too permissive?
Talk it through with Debbie Reber's guidance
Bring a request that turned into a standoff this week, in the words you used. Guidance built on Debbie Reber's authorized content can help you decide which demands to drop for now, reword the ones that stay, and plan what to say to other adults who see it differently.
- “My 12-year-old won't get in the car for school no matter how I ask. Where do we start?”
- “I dropped most demands at home, and now my daughter refuses even things she enjoys. Did I go too far?”
- “My 10-year-old shuts down if I even ask 'are you okay?' What do I say instead?”
What if your child's teacher thinks lowering demands is just giving in?
Try HumanUp free on iPhone or iPad. No credit card required.
HumanUp is currently available on iPhone and iPad. Join the Android waitlist for updates.
🔒 Your conversations are never read by a person · Built on trusted expert guidanceFrequently Asked Questions
Lowering demands and changing how you ask can help whether or not there's a label, so you don't need an answer to start. Notice what makes things easier and what makes them harder. If anything about your child's health or development worries you, your pediatrician is the right person to ask.
Consider stepping back to lower the demand level and offering alternatives, like taking a break or engaging in a calming activity, before retrying the request.
Rewards set by an adult can feel like one more demand, so they often add pressure. If something motivating does help, it tends to work best when your child has a real say in it, rather than as something held out in front of them.